Showing posts with label Star Trek. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Star Trek. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

For Nerd Eyes Only

Gene Roddenberry may have created Star Trek, but in a way he was the show's greatest predator, and his ideas for Star Trek II (Kirk and Company travel back in time to the Kennedy assassination) may have been poison in celluloid form and symptomatic of a larger problem of Roddenberry's - namely, that in three short seasons he revisited some of the same recursive formulas - this time mimeographing the chemical composition of City on the Edge of Forever. When Harve Bennett was hired by Paramount to create a sequel out of the ashes of The Motion Picture, he conspired with Jack B. Sowards to write a script that was tailored together by director Nicholas Meyer into its present permutation. Roddenberry never agreed with Bennett's vision of the future - in a way, he birthed something and had it stripped from him as other people coaxed it along and nurtured it - but shedding old skin amounts to an unemotional process. An executive must have the fortitude to stop the guy in charge creatively from driving himself and others over the edge of a cliff, even if it is on a gilded road, and the simultaneous foresight to make the calculated risk of choosing a visionary to carry the franchise forward.

Star Trek Nemesis tried to sweep away some of the old talent in order to emulate the approach taken with The Wrath of Khan, but this time the stakes were a dying franchise. Berman was still on board, but John Logan ruddered the screenplay efforts, and Stuart Baird, a long time editor with Warner Bros., was assigned to direct the picture. But unlike Bennett, who treated Star Trek with the reverence it deserved and telegraphed it with his exhaustive consultation of the original series before work began, Baird had absolutely no pulse on The Next Generation. I am sometimes loathe to blame writers. This is a director's field, and in the hands of a bad director, the writer might not like the treatment given to their scripts anymore than we do.

But Nemesis sidestepped much of the character work that made Khan so good, supplanting Star Trek as a lame action vehicle for illogic and bad science. Thematically, it was a blank piece of paper with only the barest hint of an outline. Beyond Kirk's age, beyond the danger of receding into his house of antiques, the James Kirk of Star Trek II was the perfect compliment to his younger self: he was a man who always had an answer and who bent reality with unwavering intolerance for loss when domineered by an ostensibly impossible situation. When he is faced with a choice between losing his ship or losing his best friend, he finds that there are no rules he can break to emancipate himself of that situation.

It's culpable of Nemesis that the episode The Best of Both Worlds did a far better job in capturing what should have been one of the movie's main themes. If you remember back, Riker was too comfortable on the Enterprise and refused to assume the captain's chair of any other ship while savvier officers passed him by. Like any good story, he was eventually forced to come into conflict with his frailties and make the tough choices that few other hot shots could make. Why does Riker want the captaincy now? Who are these people and how did they get here? Following the Dominion War, Worf only seems like he's aboard because it's in Dorn's contract. Data's sacrifice is a noble gesture of humanity, but there is no bearing in what he has done since First Contact. When B4 is needed most to provide a contrast to Data, he is cast aside by the plot, and he is too much of an idiot to absorb anything that Data tells him: Data would have made an excellent teacher. Nemesis should have been a referendum to explore the changing lives of the crew in the fifteen years that they had been together. Instead, it amounted to a wasted opportunity. The best part of the movie comes in the dying moments. As Riker tries to recall his first meeting with Data, the camera zooms in on Picard, evoking a similar shot in One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. Picard is given a moment of introspection, but it does not last, and Riker's memory fails him. That's kind of how I felt about this film...everything forgotten.

One of the hardest things to do is to turn inward with introspection and question your liabilities because you might find that you are no longer needed - or worse, not good enough to rise to the occasion - and just like Roddenberry before him, I feel that his protegee Rick Berman did not recognize this. Elevating Braga to producer was a mistake - Braga was a competent boilerplate writer when he had the established crew of The Next Generation to work with, but he was limited. Roger Ebert in reviewing Nemesis said that, in some uncertain terms, Star Trek was tired, bloated, collapsing in on itself with its own mystique, lost in an infinite regression, and yet like a political campaign Berman forged ahead with four more years, twisting the knife through the heart of a dying franchise. Ten years earlier, Harve Bennett originally had eyes on doing a recast for the upcoming Star Trek VI that featured the crew in their academy days (presented in flashbacks so that it could feature Shatner and Company). Back then I think the idea was somewhat misguided because Bennett and Meyer were masters of their fate, and the risk of an academy treatment in the wrong context might have been averse to Star Trek's increasing popularity with the proverbial transference of the torch to the TNG crew imminent. In 2008 the time is not only right - it's the only way to revive Star Trek.

What strikes me most about JJ Abrams - and I suspect this is why he got the job - is that he has a panache for character work, a verve for humor, and a wild sense of sci-fi and mystery. Meyer brought a very practical and naval masterstroke to Star Trek, and though Roddenberry couldn't always see it, that evolution was as much in retrospect a celebration of Star Trek as it was an attempt to preserve it and move it forward. Abrams will return to the values of the original series. That it is a time travel plot is incidental. With his academy script, Bennett saw that it was necessary to contrast the old cast with the new cast in order to make the juxtaposition palpable. This time Nimoy represents in its totality the old arc, and it will form the basis of the film.

I don't think that roles should be proprietary. Fans may hold characters up to be icons - what they want to see is the old character, but they know that it would be treasonous to duplicate the performances. The benefit in bringing in a new actor is that he'll have a different take on the part. There was nothing in Shatner's acting ability that couldn't be surpassed (this isn't like recasting Brando's Corleone), and there are ways a new actor could play Kirk that weren't necessarily in Shatner's range, so I say that change is good. If Pine is trying to play the same Kirk, then it won't live up. But if it's an alteration of the character based on what the script calls for (and he has license to do this since it's a younger Kirk), then the alteration is warranted. It might be Kirk, but it's a different kind of Kirk, just like how Craig is a different kind of Bond with his own set of strengths and weaknesses.

Paramount is investing a lot into this project - $150 million, which is just about as much as any Star Trek film has grossed worldwide (although Star Trek is a breeding ground for merchandise, so there is a lot of revenue that is not factored in). Paramount has never even invested more than $50 million into a Star Trek film, but the price of creating a blockbuster has become expensive, and the awareness of the Star Trek brand is far reaching, so it's a matter of selling the film to the right people. This film is a new beginning, one that require neither a history book nor a tech manual. The danger in sci-fi is that it can be completely unrelatable. Showing the Enterprise built plate by plate by men with blow torches humanizes it a bit. Star Trek has always treated technology as something cold and technical, which is great for fans who love the mythology, but it's not so great for everybody else. I trust in the ability of Abrams to make something palatable for fans and newcomers. Nimoy seems to think that Abrams is on the right track too, and when it comes to Star Trek, I have always trusted his opinion. He has proved that he is not an apologist, which is what Star Trek needs: an honest look at itself.

Wednesday, August 27, 2008

A Trek Through Time

Star Trek: The Next Generation had a style that was best nurtured as something eclectic, as scripts were often received in venal mercenary pacts from outside the writing staff. I myself felt like I was once part of this organism, then I fell out it, and then I reintegrated myself back into it. Its values favor those who are apprehended by rich, interconnected worlds, but the best of Star Trek chafes against the very grain of its stereotype. Star Trek is still sci fi and has been pigeonholed for a good reason, but these works are very human, very dramatic, and the stories have plenty of verve. Theory: sci fi writers are introspective, thoughtful, idea oriented, strapped to their own imaginations. A lot of them have trouble writing good characters. Even fewer write good dialog. They are transfixed by the universe but don't necessarily understand people, and so they write about the universe. There are numerous exceptions, but I think that there is some truth to that. And so I want to honor what I feel are the very best and most human episodes of The Next Generation in its long and treasured run.

I seldom see The Offspring crop up on many lists, but it is Patrick Stewart's favorite episode, and I share the sentiment. Jonathan Frakes's directorial debut, written by René Echevarria, finds fertile ground in the opening acts. Data has the ability to create life and yet does not understand the implications of it. The episode has excellent pacing, and there is a nice montage with a voice over from Data that is most impactful in sequence because it shows Lal trying to emulate human behavior. It's quick and orderly, and the impact would be lost if it was unabridged. In fact, the episode features a misdirection, as it spends most of its time debating the qualifications of Data as a parent and ends with Lal's inadvertent death. Admiral Haftel almost becomes the stock villain but is instead expertly used as a Trojan Horse to evoke sympathy at the end - the man who thought that Lal would be better served in a laboratory gives an almost frightening eulogy as he informs Picard that he couldn't follow the speed of Data's hands as he tries to save Lal. In a strange way Data cannot love but instead shows how much he cares, and it is enough to convince Haftel and shake him to his core.

Another underrated episode is the fourth season's The Drumhead (also directed by Frakes, written by Jeri Taylor). This episode works as a triumvirate. In the opening acts we are treated to the threat of a Romulan collaborator (a Klingon no less) linked to a larger conspiracy. Immediately the viewer is set with expectations, and for a time he's obliged; a medical technician, the diffident Simon Tarsus, is questioned in conjunction with the investigation and is revealed to have Romulan blood. The initial cover up binds it all together, never mind the fact that it was necessitated by his approval to Starfleet Academy. Worf takes on the perspective of the audience: he pushes the conspiracy angle hard before his realization that the trial has become a tragedy, then a farce. This is to mirror the emotions of the viewer. Jean Simmons gives an excellent portrayal of Rear Admiral Norah Satie, who initially establishes herself as a rational, eloquent woman. We only know who she is because of what we see of her. She is obviously an inveterate, distinguished person. Is the episode trying to say that a righteous vigilanti can appear rationale and eloquent? Or did she just go too far?

The Inner Light (which, curiously enough, was filmed almost exclusively on an indoor set) is often cited as the very best of TNG, a national prizefighter if you will. I am more agnostic here; I believe that it could be, but I'm not entirely convinced. The previous two episodes used pacing and structure to provide the dramatic hook and enhance the story. The emotional resonance of The Inner Light hinges almost completely on the premise: an alien probe from a ruined world forces Picard to relive a lifetime of events in only 25 minutes. But the episode is very honest. Picard's life on the Enterprise fades in reflection, and with that existence on the fringe, he becomes something that he would never oblige himself as a starship captain. He becomes a family man. The juxtaposition of these two realities works well. One of the final scenes featured some excellent acting from Stewart as his family and friends, timelessly preserved as their younger selves, tell him that he is burdened with carrying the weight of a long dead civilization.

A lot of reasons are given for why Tapestry succeeds: Picard relives a life he once reviled and becomes something he hates even more, context is given for his famous laugh at the edge of a knife, established in Samaritan Snare, and of course it was written by Ronald D. Moore. Beyond that, however, the first thirty minutes could have been very dry with the outcome already in place. These initial segments work for two reasons: 1) Picard's life is at stake, and at the end of the episode he would rather choose death than a safe, comfortable life, and 2) Picard hates the young man he is forced to live as, and it exacerbates the issue when Q provides commentary. Picard is given the opportunity to live his earlier days as he lives as captain of the Enterprise, which ironically ends his career before it begins. Foresight can be dangerous, and it is only through the spontaneity of life that we learn from our mistakes.

I am not going to delineate much about The Best of Both Worlds, but its strengths provide context as to why much of later Trek failed: it pushed the crew to the brink, forced them to make tough decisions, and was anything but predictable storytelling.

  © Blogger template 'A Click Apart' by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP